Categories: Social Media

Calling Mashable´s bluff; if GooglePlus is a ghost town then Facebook and Twitter are Cemeteries

*Battle of the Social Networks – Who Will Win In Terms Of Interactions On The Same Published Story*?

+Mashable  has release another story about G+ being a site of "low activity" complete with Infograph stats that really make no sense. I'm frankly tired of these articles and pictures,  So today I did some resarch and made my very own pretty picture, comparing some articles that Mashable has published in the last 24 hours and how much Social Media buzz they got across the various networks. I bring you… 

What are the ACTUAL Interaction Results across Google+, Twitter and Facebook (with pictures and numbers) for the same story from Mashable?

STORY  :Would You Wear an Internet-Connected T-Shirt?… (also conveniently by Mr    who wrote this G+ ghost town article) – http://mashable.com/2012/08/08/internet-connected-t-shirt/
Google+ Summary  –
• 810 +1s
• 415 Reshares
• 265 Comments (not including all the comments and plus ones from each of those 415 reshares of course) ….

Twitter Summary – (http://twitter.com/mashable/status/233175795370172416)
• 32  Favorites
• 130 RT  
• 5  @Replies 

Facebook Summary – (https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10151304555674705&set=a.76650969704.71443.18807449704&type=1)
• 249 Likes
• 97  Shares
• 38  Comments

G+ hands down winner here.

Let's compare another one shall we? 

STORY  : Not on Facebook? Employers, Psychiatrists May Think You’re a Psychopath  – http://mashable.com/2012/08/07/no-facebook-psychopath/

Google+ Summary
• 386 +1s 
• 337 Comments
• 324 ReShares 

Twitter Summary – (http://twitter.com/mashable/status/233155694054998016)
• 44  Favorites
• 120 RT 
• 2  @Replies

Facebook Summary – (https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10151302812799705&set=a.76650969704.71443.18807449704&type=1)
• 394 Likes
• 78  Comments
• 345 Shares

FB was close but over all G+ wins again! (Especially including the comments and +s on all 324 reshares)

These numbers were accurate as of the time of this post as you can see by clicking to enlarge the lovely graphic below . 🙂

I would REALLY like to stress that both Facebook and Twitter have various APIs that allow their numbers to be automated, for example Auto RT everything Mashable says. None of these are possible on G+ because there is NO personal write API. Real people are manually doing each one of these actions on the stats listed above on Google Plus. 

The point i am trying to stress here in bright clear numbers is that G+ has a way  higher level of engagement than the other two on the same story… How on EARTH can you post G+ has low engagement on your website when this site is actually giving you WAY better engagement?

I really hope someday soon we can stop seeing these link bait articles about how "dead and ghost town" Google plus it is. Its simply false sensationalized reporting.

If you are finding G+ a bit isolated, circle some more people, join a public hangout or gosh darn it try posting and commenting here once a day using some trending hashtags, pretty pictures and stuff you are interested in! 

It can be life changing experience to find your voice and make a noise here on G+.

 

Amanda Blain

Business Owner & Geek Girl. Likes Technology, Virtual Reality, Video Games & Social Media. Previously Famous on the Internet I'm press at a few places. I own this site, World Of Geek Stuff -https://www.worldofgeekstuff.com and Girlfriend Social - https://www.girlfriendsocial.com

View Comments

  • I think its just trendy to make comments about how something sucks so you can get irate people posting about you publicizing your stupidity

  • I know where the argument is coming from that G+ is a "ghost town"....  but if people would just follow the advice of many and actually put just a little bit of effort into it.....  sigh
    Great example - I'm not surprised in the least.

  • Thanks for taking the time to compare the numbers. It really does prove G+ is not a ghost town.

  • The interesting thing I've noticed,  is: G+ stuff gets shared on G+ and Facebook stuff on Facebook, but everything still gets shared on Twitter. I'm not so much making a point here; I'm just making an observation

  •   Well if facebook had an os, a cell phone, or a cloud maybe facebook could have such posts but right now its just a glorified message board...

Share
Published by
Amanda Blain

Recent Posts

How To Cast Oculus Quest 2 VR to TV, Computer, Phone and Mixed Reality

If you want to show your friends what you are playing in VR, follow this…

3 years ago

How to Install Virtual Desktop on Oculus Quest 2 and Play SteamVR Wirelessly

So you bought a Quest 2 and want to wireless connect to your PC, play…

3 years ago

Is VR Safe For Kids? Can Kids Use the Meta Quest 2 VR?

Your children have requested a Meta Quest 2 VR headset because all their friends are…

3 years ago

Must Have Popular VR Oculus Quest 2 Games

What are the must-have VR Oculus Quest 2 Games? Much like all video games, there…

3 years ago

Should You Buy The Oculus Quest 2? Is VR ready?

Its finally here! Facebook has released the quest 2, but should you get it? Which…

4 years ago

What is 5G and Is it Harmful to Our Health?

What is 5G Wireless Technology? 5G (Fifth Generation of Wireless Technology) is actually really cool,…

4 years ago